Skip to main content

Digital minds

Who are the agents here?

2012-03-16 — 2026-10-20

quality 3.7

In Which the Cacophony Model Is Observed, Shane Legg, Fernando Rosas, and Anil Seth Are Linked via the Arvomm Repository, and the Frantic Disputations Regarding Consciousness Are Regarded With a Heavy, Listless Sigh.

how do science
intractable
mind
snarks

Is the question of whether digital mind-like behaviour is a matter of simulationism, moral patienthood, or “consciousness”? I don’t know. Let’s watch people flap about trying to work out what the question even is.

1 The cacophony model

Any good? I don’t know, but it features Shane Legg, Fernando Rosas, and Anil Seth collaborating, so it’s certainly doing something interesting.

2 References

Chandaria, Morán, Rosas, et al. 2026. “From Cacophony to Hierarchy: A Principled Framework for Assessing AI Consciousness.”
Schwitzgebel. 2026. AI and Consciousness: A Skeptical Overview.
Searle. 1980. “Minds, Brains, and Programs.” The Behavioral and Brain Sciences.