Designing social movements

Synthetic biology for utopian egregores

May 1, 2021 — March 24, 2024

collective knowledge
game theory
incentive mechanisms
social graph

On the theory of designing the precepts of self-replicating social groups. Important in “community stewardship”. Probably uses tools from institutions, social norms etc.

To discuss: Bay area rationalists, the Marrickville Warehouse Alliance, weirdo Honduran charter cities, every Schelling model, (de-)radicalization pathways…

Figure 1

1 Set up

  • Welcome to The FORGE! | The Forge

    The FORGE is a new online journal by and for organizers. The Forge is being built to fortify the strategy and practice of organizing through the sharing of ideas, methods, history, and inspiration. It is a space for building connection and community among organizers and across sectors of the progressive movement.

2 As community

See community maintenance.

3 On social norms

See social norms.

4 On governance and accountability

See community governance.

5 On non-monetary economies

Governance of community as governance of (some real or imagined) commons.

Figure 2

5.1 Status within

See status for now. Later return to the idea of multiple hierarchies in The Melancholy of Subculture Society footnotes.

6 OODA loops in movements


7 Structuring

8 Institutions

Why Woke Organizations All Sound the Same: is a criticism of social justice agendas, but it is also a laundry list of theory-of-change ideas for persuading institutions to implement your preferred agenda, whether that agenda be socially just or socially unjust, or not particularly concerned with justice.

9 Within wider society

Fascinating parallels in outgroups and mobilisation against other outgroups: Katie J. M. Baker on a lady manosphere analogue: Mumsnet

The more I learned about Mumsnet, the more the forum reminded me of my past reporting on the ways men are radicalized by the toxic online “manosphere,” where pick-up artists (PUAs) and men’s rights activists (MRAs) recruit followers by exploiting real fears (such as economic anxiety) and blaming marginalized outgroups (women, people of color, Jews) for societal failures. As people get drawn into these communities, they become obsessed with a misguided sense of victimization and start to focus single-mindedly on their newfound worldview.

It seemed to me that was exactly what was happening on Mumsnet: some of these newly “gender critical” Mumsnetters were relatively privileged women who had never felt marginalized until they gave birth and came to feel isolated in their nuclear households and (rightfully!) outraged at the lack of support for mothers in the U.K. They turned to Mumsnet for solidarity, and somehow became fixated on trans women in the process

I take issue with some of the analyses in this article, of both Mumsnet and the MRAs, but the general thesis about the similarity in recruiting, onboarding and mobilising dynamics is interesting.

See also emancipating my tribe.

10 Movements For Good People

Over at institutions for angels I muse about movement design that presupposes its members are good.

11 Recruitment bias

David Rosenthal on Cryptocurrencies argues

Libertarianism’s attraction is based on ignoring externalities, and cryptocurrencies are no exception.

Zing. All ideologies face a disjunct between of what their core theorists advocate and what their recruiting implicitly advocates in terms of who gets lured in. The best version of communism is probably the one that wishes that lazy people who want free stuff would not join up and advocate it. And principled libertarian theorists presumably don’t want advocates who only want the freedom to pollute and shoot things all day long. And yet, ultimately the movement may be dominated by the worst version of itself. Libertarianism has this to such an extreme though. What can we learn from that?

12 Moral cultures

There is a provocative article, Campbell and Manning (2014), which argues about microaggression in terms of moral cultures of, in order, Honor, Dignity, and Victimhood (Crib sheet). Tanner Greer likes that take too. It is an interesting perspective, although not mine. I do like the notion of moral cultures, though. What is just?

13 Hygiene and inner circles

Hypocrisy, mottes, baileys, inter-cultural etiquette.

Adam Elkus, Vampire-Hunting As A Vocation.

14 Glue beliefs

See tribal rituals and beliefs.

15 LARPing

Faking it until you make it, or just faking it?.

16 The cult spectrum

Young (2022) places the Children of God and the US military on a spectrum of cultiness and argues that both are exemplars of a particular type of group configuration.

17 Incoming

Fascinating analysis from a conservative perspective, Why is Everything Liberal?.

Fascinating business-behavioural portfolio: Francesca Gino. (Update: did not pan out; see Data Falsificada (Part 1): “Clusterfake”).

18 References

Aydinonat. 2008. The Invisible Hand in Economics: How Economists Explain Unintended Social Consequences.
Baldassarri, and Grossman. 2013. The Effect of Group Attachment and Social Position on Prosocial Behavior. Evidence from Lab-in-the-Field Experiments.” Edited by Angel Sánchez. PLoS ONE.
Baron. 2005. So Right It’s Wrong: Groupthink and the Ubiquitous Nature of Polarized Group Decision Making.” In Advances in Experimental Social Psychology.
Bergstrom. 2002. Evolution of Social Behavior: Individual and Group Selection.” The Journal of Economic Perspectives.
Bowles. 2001. Individual Interactions, Group Conflicts, and the Evolution of Preferences.” Social Dynamics.
Boyd, and Richerson. 1992. Punishment Allows the Evolution of Cooperation (or Anything Else) in Sizable Groups.” Ethology and Sociobiology.
Bretherton, and Dunbar. 2020. Dunbar’s Number Goes to Church: The Social Brain Hypothesis as a Third Strand in the Study of Church Growth.” Archive for the Psychology of Religion.
Bruner, Justin P. 2015. Diversity, Tolerance, and the Social Contract.” Politics, Philosophy & Economics.
Bruner, Justin P. 2021. Cooperation, Correlation and the Evolutionary Dominance of Tag-Based Strategies.” Biology & Philosophy.
Campbell, and Manning. 2014. Microaggression and Moral Cultures.” Comparative Sociology.
Cantu, and Jussim. 2021. Microaggressions, Questionable Science, and Free Speech.” SSRN Scholarly Paper ID 3822628.
Cheng, Tracy, and Henrich. 2010. Pride, Personality, and the Evolutionary Foundations of Human Social Status.” Evolution and Human Behavior.
Chu, and Evans. 2021. Slowed Canonical Progress in Large Fields of Science.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
Couzin, Ioannou, Demirel, et al. 2011. Uninformed Individuals Promote Democratic Consensus in Animal Groups.” Science.
DeDeo, and Hobson. 2021. From Equality to Hierarchy.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
Demetriou. 2016. Fighting Together: Civil Discourse and Agonistic Honor.” In Honor in the Modern World: Interdisciplinary Perspectives. Honor and Obligation in Liberal Society: Problems and Prospects.
Dowding. 2016. Albert O. Hirschman, Exit, Voice and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States.” In Albert O. Hirschman,.
Dunbar. 1993. Coevolution of Neocortex Size, Group Size and Language in Humans.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences.
Gould. 2002. The Origins of Status Hierarchies: A Formal Theory and Empirical Test.” American Journal of Sociology.
Hayward. 1999. Mathematical Modeling of Church Growth.” The Journal of Mathematical Sociology.
———. 2005. A General Model of Church Growth and Decline.” The Journal of Mathematical Sociology.
Henrich, and Boyd. 1998. The Evolution of Conformist Transmission and the Emergence of Between-Group Differences.” Evolution and Human Behavior.
Heydari Fard. 2018. Decision-Theoretic Consequentialism and the Desire-Luck Problem.” Journal of Cognition and Neuroethics.
———. 2021. Complexity Theory in the Lived Experience of a Seasoned Activist: Review of Shut It Down: Stories from a Fierce, Loving Resistance.” The Acorn.
———. 2022. Strategic Injustice, Dynamic Network Formation, and Social Movements.” Synthese.
———. 2024. The Transformative Power of Social Movements.” Philosophy Compass.
Hirsch. 2013. Social Limits to Growth.” In Social Limits to Growth.
Hirschman. 1970. Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States.
Horst, Kirman, and Teschl. 2007. Changing Identity: The Emergence of Social Groups.” Economics Working Paper 0078.
Klug, and Bagrow. 2016. Understanding the Group Dynamics and Success of Teams.” Royal Society Open Science.
Köster, Hadfield-Menell, Everett, et al. 2022. Spurious Normativity Enhances Learning of Compliance and Enforcement Behavior in Artificial Agents.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
Lilienfeld. 2017. Microaggressions: Strong Claims, Inadequate Evidence.” Perspectives on Psychological Science.
Maner. 2017. Dominance and Prestige: A Tale of Two Hierarchies.” Current Directions in Psychological Science.
Mäs, Flache, Takács, et al. 2013. In the Short Term We Divide, in the Long Term We Unite: Demographic Crisscrossing and the Effects of Faultlines on Subgroup Polarization.” Organization Science.
Matlock, and Sen. 2007. Effective Tag Mechanisms for Evolving Coordination.” In Proceedings of the 6th International Joint Conference on Autonomous Agents and Multiagent Systems. AAMAS ’07.
McClure. 2017. ‘Go and Do Likewise’: Investigating Whether Involvement in Congregationally Sponsored Community Service Activities Predicts Prosocial Behavior.” Review of Religious Research.
Nagai. 2017. The Pseudo-Science of Microaggressions.” Academic Questions.
Niemeyer, Veri, Dryzek, et al. 2023. How Deliberation Happens: Enabling Deliberative Reason.” American Political Science Review.
Nowak. 2006. Five Rules for the Evolution of Cooperation.” Science.
O’Connor. 2022. “Why Natural Social Contracts Are Not Fair.”
Olson. 2009. The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups.
Pavlogiannis, Tkadlec, Chatterjee, et al. 2018. Construction of Arbitrarily Strong Amplifiers of Natural Selection Using Evolutionary Graph Theory.” Communications Biology.
Silver, Byrne, and Adler. 2021. Venues and Segregation: A Revised Schelling Model.” PLOS ONE.
Talhelm, and Dong. 2024. People Quasi-Randomly Assigned to Farm Rice Are More Collectivistic Than People Assigned to Farm Wheat.” Nature Communications.
Trouche, Sander, and Mercier. 2014. Arguments, More Than Confidence, Explain the Good Performance of Reasoning Groups.” SSRN Scholarly Paper ID 2431710.
van den Bergh, and Gowdy. 2009. A Group Selection Perspective on Economic Behavior, Institutions and Organizations.” Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization.
van der Post, Franz, and Laland. 2016. Skill Learning and the Evolution of Social Learning Mechanisms.” BMC Evolutionary Biology.
Weinersmith, Weinersmith, Abramitzky, et al. 2023. To Each According to Their Space-Need: Communes in Outer Space.” Space Policy.
Woodley, and Pratt. 2020. The CSCCE Community Participation Model – A Framework to Describe Member Engagement and Information Flow in STEM Communities.”
Young. 2022. Uncultured: A Memoir.